A former head of NATO, Anders Fogh Rasmussen has said that Britain and France should immediately deploy troops to Ukraine. He describes the Coalition of the Willing more as a 'coalition of the waiting'.
I would go further and suggest that as many nations who can do the same should join this move. In what one might call 'normal times' one would have expected the USA to be in the forefront of such a move but it seems that those currently negotiating with Russia are interested more in making business deals than peace on any terms that could be described as even vaguely reasonable.
A large move of this sort, with forces primarily still in defence mode, merely helping to counter missiles destroying property and making it clear that any attempt to advance by Russia would have a lot more Ukrainian troops now available to resist any advance, would show the resolve and strength of feeling across most of Europe. Indeed, add some support from British Commonwealth countries and that support can be seen as broadly worldwide and not something Russia can easily challenge.
This should have happened years ago.
Someone has to make a move of some sort, sooner or later. Putin's plan is pretty plain to see; continue to push at various points along the existing front line and continue to destroy more and more of Ukraine's towns and infrastructure. The destruction in the capital and other towns is already vast, with no-one now feeling safe anywhere in the country with the possible exception of the furthest western regions. Even there, attacks at border points where Russia knows they can achieve the greatest number of casualties and feed further the fear amongst people, are having their desired effect and I doubt it will be long before some massive missiles reach Lviv and other places there too.
Following this through, the logical conclusion has to be that, slowly, Ukraine is degraded to a wreck of a country with little surviving services and dangerous buildings in all towns and cities where people find it increasingly difficult to live. Supplies of all vital services will diminish to levels where serious health issues can arise and simply being cold and hungry can lower even the hardiest of resistance fighters. For all that Ukraine will not give in. Whether Zelensky remains as President or some other person takes over the will of the country is not to give in. Ukraine troops will continue to fight as best they can and, even if USA reduce their support, they will continue to use advanced techniques and hold many of the lines they have held for all this time. This can go on for years, literally, and despite all the bombing and cold and whatever else nature throws at them, Ukraine will retain its independence and resist any significant Russian advance. That is, of course, unless Russia decides to change its tactics to go for the quicker win.
Many of us are surprised that they have not taken an option to use chemical weapons or even a small nuclear device to eliminate a town, or, if that seems too extreme and actually poses a risk to their own troops and population in the event of winds blowing in the wrong direction, they have always had the option of simply deploying what we have thought are their vast military resources to blast all the Ukraine defences to smithereens and scorch the rest of the nation with a massive attack of missiles of all sorts other than the very nastiest. One has to wonder why this option has not been taken. I can appreciate why the nuclear and chemical options have been resisted as either would really result in the world closing ranks against them but a massive attack using all that they have available ought to be considered.
Perhaps the reason it has not been considered is that it does not exist. Could Ukraine's raids and demolition of huge numbers of Russian troops over the years, certainly nearing 500,000 killed or incapacitated, and smart targeting of military facilities have really diminished Russia's ability to mount any substantial attack?
Could it simply be that Russia is doing its best at the moment. Holding a front line only by losing 2000 men a day and firing whatever they have at towns and villages every day, like a naughty schoolboy throwing stones across the garden wall and running away afterwards.
Russia has been very careful so far not obviously to hit a NATO country. Yes, they have been responsible for many borderline actions and may well have been responsible for some definite incursions which could have triggered Article 5 but we have chosen to stay quiet and see what happens rather than respond in any way at all. It seems that they do not wish to cast the first stone against NATO, content just to chuck a few pebbles at some windows and claim it was someone else.
We now have the complete farce of Trump calling Putin 'my friend' and berating European leaders for supporting Ukraine's long distance strikes on Russian oil and military resources. You simply could not have written this episode and expected anyone to have believed it.
Over and again I repeat that there has to be some action now. There has to be some military move made by whichever nations across Europe and the Commonwealth are willing to support Ukraine. Troops on the ground in Ukraine. Planes in the skies around Ukraine. Major diplomatic action too - statements by leaders not just to say they will 'stand by, with or for' Ukraine but that they declare an absolute abhorrence to what Russia is doing and will not trade with any country who continues to support Russia. We have to isolate every government that is helping Russia to survive and causing so much pain to Ukraine and its people.
Someone really does need to stand up, indeed, and show some leadership in this. There must surely be politicians or people of some substance in USA who can come out and inspire their nation to do the right thing, take down the idiot Trump and all his business partners who are making the running at the moment, make him powerless and just some joke of a president for the next two years while whoever can talk sense gets on with the job he should have been doing.
And where are the students, the demonstrations, the placards, demanding a counter to Russia's terrible actions? Where is the United Nations? Where is the World Health Organisation? Where are all the international bodies, charities and the like that we give money to so that they can help people in trouble, identify wrong and call out evil when it is evident that one nation, supported by some others from time to time, is totally and absolutely wrong, wrong and wrong again.
Nothing that Russia has done since their first invasion of Crimea, possibly even before that, has been in any way forgivable and yet here we are, with Trump calling Putin a friend, North Korea providing troops and material and hacking resources with hardly any comment from anyone, Iran providing missiles and, oddly damaging American bases while Trump seems not to notice as he heaps praise on the Russia that is working with that very same Iran. It would be laughable if it were not so damn sad.
If we cannot regard the scenario we see today as something that the good people of countries like ours have to do something about, if we cannot intervene and stop the bully from beating up the little kid, we deserve whatever we get in years to come. That may well be lessons in Russian for our children's children and some sort of Union of Socialist European States.
Politicians may say how much they support Ukraine but it is time that we decide whether we as individuals are prepared actually to do something. Many may be raising money or collecting goods to transport to the country. Others may be providing accommodation and protection here in Britain for women and children who have escaped the country. Countries are providing a lot of money for the country, helping to purchase and supply weapons and our forces are providing training and intelligence. These are welcome and solid assistance but are predominantly things that don't hurt, don't inconvenience us. Indeed, most of us continue to go about our daily lives with little thought of Ukraine. No-one reads newspapers these days but even if they did they would seldom see much about Ukraine nowadays. Most people's news now comes via a social media stream and, unless they have specifically signed up for a podcast or details of developments which might affect Ukraine, whatever happens there has little or no impact on their day. The number of people that I talk to who are shocked when I mention that a friend's children have to go to school underground, that another is disturbed by siren warnings every night and sometimes missiles hit buildings nearby, that people are being killed every day and hundreds injured every day in that country is extraordinary. They are not stupid people, just ignorant. They have little or no idea of what life is like for good people and children in Ukraine. They are not aware that Russian troops are trying to demolish whole towns and schools and hospitals, hitting buses and trains and taxis. So many people now have no reliable water supply, nor heating for hours on end in temperatures dropping below zero and soon to get far colder. However many times I write about this, it seems very few people really appreciate how bad life is for these good people and how it will only get better if Russia stops firing missiles and stops attacking towns and stops controlling areas where the population doesn't want them.
Can my countrymen have any idea of what life is like in most of Ukraine? No. I am sure they cannot and I do not blame them for that. I blame the media and the government for not taking real action to back up their promise to 'stand by' Ukraine. This has to become headline news. We need to take real action. Troops must be sent to Ukraine and in such quantities that it is obvious to Russia that they will be obliged to fight all of us.
Just as Ukraine is not giving in and Russia is unlikely to achieve any significant advance other than flattening more and more premises and buildings and factories, Russia would not achieve much against any of its new challengers. Just one missile fired at one of the NATO countries would lead to a response that would reduce their capability to fire more to such an extent that they would almost certainly not wish to make that move. Russia is not a strong military country any more. It can be beaten. Russia has nuclear weapons but everyone is aware that firing just one would lead to major loss for them too. Russia will not start a nuclear war.
Russia may well cause significant inconvenience for all of us in the West by cutting internet links, communications cables, hacking into key infrastructure and wrecking many of our systems. They will always do so via other actors and there will never be that evidence required for us to respond in a major way. These actions won't kill us, though, and we will continue to help Ukraine push Russia back to earlier boundaries and, together with Ukraine, we can inflict just as much inconvenience for Russian citizens too.
In the continued absence of any 'Article 5' event, and even if there were one it is unclear that NATO would respond with any military action as NATO, it is likely that a group of nations will be those that make the difference.
Prince Harry declared that he would serve for his country if asked. OK, so he would not have much choice as a reservist anyway, but the fact that he has announced clearly that he regards Russia's actions as appalling and needing to be stopped and that he is willing to assist in doing so is good to hear. despite his dubious activities in other fields over the years, his commitment to this is sound and may be something he could champion. Our government and several others in Europe have responded to Trump telling them to stop funding Ukraine by doubling down on their verbal support. That's good to hear too. Now let these people get some boots on the ground and planes in the sky.
As for putting my own words into action, I doubt that I would be of much assistance in any physical form of battle but I do want to do something. I am prepared to help supply materials to Ukraine, drive there, work with organisations there to manage projects and, of course, carry on writing as much as I can and, perhaps, writing from being on the ground in Ukraine as opposed to safely ensconced in England if that will somehow lead to others doing something too.
No comments:
Post a Comment