Things are not improving in the world. Indeed, I am becoming increasingly frustrated with the Powers That Be on several fronts. There is the farcical situation in Scotland as from a few days time when people will be able to drop in at one of hundreds of Reporting Centres and make accusations anonymously against whomsoever they please which will be recorded by Police Scotland and, extraordinarily it seems, listed as a hate crime on one’s police offences record which would be visible on any DBS documents that have to be provided to an employer for many types of new or continued employment.
In order to make a complaint an individual appears merely to state that they have been offended by something said and this might even apply not only to something reported by a child as being said by a parent or by a fictitious character in a story.
From April it will become a crime to use “threatening or abusive” behaviour with the intention of stirring up hatred on the basis of religion, age, disability, sexual orientation and transgender identity. The definition of what comprises “threatening” or “abusive” appears to favour the perception of the reporter rather than any evidenced belief or views of the person accused. So if I lived in Scotland I could pop into one of these Centres and claim that a neighbour or just someone in the street or at work was saying things or behaving in a way that I found threatening or abusive and that would be that for the person concerned. No-one will be checking whether anything was said or not, never mind the extent to which it might be threatening or abusive or the degree to which I might wish to cause trouble for anyone by such action. It’s all crazy stuff and actually quite scary and those journalists who have had the courage to start writing about this are comparing the scene up across the border to life as it might have been with Stasi intervention and reporting my people on one another in East Germany in the 1960s. I use the word “courage” in the previous remark as you may have figured out that the journalists themselves could well find themselves reported as they, by showing disagreement or objection to the new law, could be regarded by some as expressing threatening or abusive behaviour, depending upon the words used and how they are perceived by someone north of the border. You see they could even report me for writing this as it will be visible to any demented soul in Scotland who may wish to claim that I am threatening or abusive.
What particularly strikes me about all this is not so much the content of the legislation but the fact that anything like this has been allowed to develop in Britain. Have our politicians no belief in freedom of speech any more? Are they too scared to upset someone by defending our rights to say and think what we please without fear? Is this not so fundamental as to eclipse all other matters that parliament needs to deal with? We gave Scotland devolution in order to placate demands for more independence and allow Scots to have a government more reflective of their own beliefs on the assumption that, certainly on local matters, those who live in or around an area are more likely to comprehend and deal with matters arising there. At no point did we in the United Kingdom as a whole reckon on the government at Edinburgh, whatever colour it may be, making decisions on matters such as gender, disability, sexual orientation etc. These are issues on which there probably needs to be no legislation whatsoever but, if someone can think of something that needs to have rules then those rules must surely have much wider application that just to those in a particular location within the United Kingdom.
There is a policy whereby the British government at Westminster, responsible for the whole of the United Kingdom, should step in when a law is proposed for one of the devolved countries which has implications for the nation as a whole and surely if anything needs to be so protected it is the right to free speech throughout the UK.
That I should need to question such freedom being at risk when there is a Conservative government at Westminster is all the more extraordinary. It is as if no-one really cares. With almost everyone now expecting a Socialist government to take over at Westminster within a year we are, as the old Scots bloke used to say in the Dad’s Army TV series, “all doomed, we’re all doomed.” Except it isn’t funny.
Then it is now more than two years since Russia invaded Ukraine and have effectively demolished vast areas, cities and claimed ownership of substantial tracts of the country in the East and South East. At first there was great hope when Ukraine showed just how good they were at defending themselves and, with great moral support from across the West generally, set about pushing back Russian advances. Now so many governments seem to have found excuses for not sending equipment or ammunition. The United States promised huge assistance but just a handful of guys we’ve never really heard of before in charge of making decisions have simply stopped anything happening. Promises broken left, right and centre. We all mouth our determination that Russia should not succeed but we seem to do very little about it.
The prospect does now loom that Ukraine will shrink to the parts to the West of Kyiv and south down to Odessa but maybe not even including that old city. Ukraine have virtually destroyed Russian naval capabilities in the region but nevertheless look like losing access to their own coastline and to become landlocked and unable easily to export anything as effectively as they used to.
Why are we so frightened of actually doing something which would end the nightmare for the Ukrainian people? Concerted action by a combined force representing a range of countries from Europe, United States, the British Commonwealth and whoever else cares which puts troops on the ground and equipment where it needs to be is what is needed to call Putin’s bluff. The only reason we don’t do this is because we are scared. We are scared on several levels. The obvious one is the threat that Putin and his comrades utter about flattening London with a nuclear attack or causing a tsunami by blasting somewhere in the ocean nearby that floods the British Isles. (Or for those in other countries replace London and other locations as appropriate.) We do have systems to intercept missiles. Ukraine, with its comparatively low-tech (initially, at any rate) detection systems managed to knock out the vast majority of Russian missiles of all sorts, including some pretty advanced stuff. There’s nothing very different about spotting a nuclear missile on its way and knocking that out before it causes any damage. So we should have some confidence in our defence systems and the fact that anything thrown at us would most surely see the return in Russia’s direction of a whole barrage from every NATO country which would certainly result in the complete destruction of Russia as a viable place to function militarily from that moment. We should know that Putin knows that and he simply is not going to fire anything like that at a NATO country. Perhaps we are scared that our depleted Army, Navy and Airforce resources would not function well and allow damage to be done here, even if it were not of the disastrous nuclear type. That is a reasonable fear as there is no doubt that we have far smaller troop numbers and equipment numbers than at any time before. We thought all that old-fashioned sort of fighting had stopped years ago. We watched how the US got beaten soundly in Vietnam and reckoned we wouldn’t even try. We did well to wrest back the Falklands from Argentina but they were hardly the most challenging of enemy. We stood by after 9/11, 7/7 and atrocities many since, talking about how bad everything was and how terrible terrorists are but hardly excelled ourselves in the field of battle in the few places we did have a go. No-one talks about Afghanistan any more. So, yes, Britain may not rule the waves these days but, with all the NATO allies and especially with France rampant at this particular time, we should not show such fear and we should say we need to do this. Someone needs to help Ukraine and the only way to do that is to be there and show Putin that he really will bring a whole load of shit down on himself and his countrymen and women if he does not withdraw.
There will almost certainly have to be an uncomfortable few weeks when Putin will not want to be shown as being beaten and some pride will need to be swallowed, I fear, with some gains by Russia being allowed to stand. I suggest a sort of independent control placed in the Eastern areas where, quite frankly, there is little Ukraine interest any more and the extent of devastation inflicted by idiot Russian attacks has rendered the areas pretty damn useless for anyone anyway. I would expect Crimea to be placed under similar independent control while people sort out its history and just who should govern the place. Ukraine has a lot of history on its side in that respect but there are some Russian arguments too which deserve attention before the place is either sliced up or given to one or the other. Otherwise Ukraine should be restored much as it was and it should be Russia that pays the whole rice of reparation. That cost will be huge and would need to come from duties from whatever products they sell in future as well as sale of whatever assets we have already acquired and do not need to return. Putin will probably escape prosecution by some means, the most likely being such a protracted and lengthy process of accusation and evidence-building, or even deciding how to go about it, that he either dies or retires comparatively gracefully and we let him get away with it because we can’t be bothered to do anything else.
The big thing I would insist upon would be the removal of all nuclear facilities from Russia. It would be unreasonable to expect them to be given to a NATO country but they most definitely should not stay there to allow some future foolish president to start this all over again. We have enough trouble in North Korea with unpredictable people more concerned with threatening us than feeding their own people. So who would look after the massive arsenal I don’t know and I would even suggest that the whole operation is done quietly and secretly, behind the scenes. That avoids embarrassment for the stupid people who started all this and also stops the world being obsessed with it all. I don’t particularly want anyone to get away with the terrible damage and suffering they caused in Ukraine but in the crucial period of negotiations on matters we need the co-operation of people in power in Russia today until it’s all said and done.
Then, by all means, we can shout victory, give Putin the biggest V sign in the history of the world and jail anyone we don’t like over there. Hopefully the Russian people will eventually come to their senses and become weaned off the diet of Socialist TV and newspapers and start to appreciate what life should really be like for free people as we assist new broadcasters and publishers slowly to get real facts and a range of different opinions voiced in their country. With a bit of luck they’ll elect some decent leaders in years to come and we might even return some of the weapons.
I don’t expect many Russians will want to visit Scotland for a while, though.
No comments:
Post a Comment